Why Your Team Fails When You Think You're Leading (And What a TOPGUN Instructor Taught Me About Real Leadership)

KS

Kamal Shukla

Founder & CEO

January 21, 2026
4 min read
Why Your Team Fails When You Think You're Leading (And What a TOPGUN Instructor Taught Me About Real Leadership)

You think you're leading. You're making decisions. You're delegating tasks. You're holding meetings.

But if your team still struggles with the same problems month after month, here's the uncomfortable truth: you're not leading. You're managing. And there's a massive difference.

Dave Berke spent years as a TOPGUN instructor, teaching the Navy's best pilots to become even better. In "The Need to Lead," co-authored with former Navy SEAL Jocko Willink , Berke distills what he learned in the cockpit into a framework that applies to every boardroom, startup, and team struggling to execute.

The Problem We Don't Want to Admit

Most of us were promoted because we were good at doing the work. We were the top salesperson, the best engineer, the most reliable individual contributor. Then we became leaders, and suddenly everything got harder.

Why? Because we never learned to lead. We learned to do.

Berke's central thesis cuts through the noise: leadership isn't about you being excellent. It's about making everyone around you excellent. And that requires a completely different skill set than the one that got you promoted.

The TOPGUN Framework for Leadership

What makes this book different from the tsunami of leadership content flooding LinkedIn? Berke doesn't give you motivational platitudes. He gives you a system.

The framework centers on what Berke calls "leading from any seat." In a fighter jet, both pilots can lead depending on the situation. The person with the best perspective on the problem leads in that moment, regardless of rank. Imagine that mindset in your organization.

Here's what actually matters according to Berke:

Clarity over complexity. When your team doesn't execute, it's rarely because they're incompetent. It's because they don't understand the mission. Berke learned this watching pilots struggle not from lack of skill, but from unclear objectives. Your team can't hit a target they can't see.

Detachment under pressure. When everything's on fire, your instinct is to dive into the weeds. Berke teaches the opposite. The leader who stays detached, who maintains perspective while others are in the details, is the leader who sees the solution everyone else misses.

Decentralized execution. You can't micromanage a dogfight at 600 mph. Berke's framework pushes decision-making to the people closest to the problem. Your job isn't to make every decision. It's to develop people who make good decisions without you.

The Leadership Lesson That Changes Everything

The most powerful insight in the book? Leadership solves every challenge.

Not strategy. Not resources. Not better people. Leadership.

That struggling project? Leadership problem. The team that can't collaborate? Leadership problem. The sales target you keep missing? Leadership problem.

This is either the most empowering or most terrifying realization you'll have this year. It means every problem in your organization traces back to you. But it also means you have the power to fix it.

What You'll Actually Learn

Berke doesn't just philosophize. He breaks down:

  • How to conduct debriefs that actually improve performance instead of assigning blame

  • The specific communication techniques that prevent 90% of team failures

  • Why your "open door policy" is probably making you a worse leader

  • How to build a culture where people take ownership instead of waiting for permission

  • The daily habits that separate leaders who inspire from managers who exhaust

The book reads like a conversation with a mentor who's seen everything go wrong and learned how to make it right. Berke's writing is direct, practical, and refreshingly free of corporate jargon.

The Bottom Line

If you're tired of leadership books that inspire you on Sunday and leave you confused on Monday, "The Need to Lead" is different. It's a manual, not a manifesto.

Berke proves what TOPGUN instructors have known for decades: leadership isn't innate. It's learnable. It's trainable. And it's the only sustainable competitive advantage your organization has.

The question isn't whether your team can perform at a higher level. The question is whether you're willing to lead them there.


Ready to transform how you lead? Pick up "The Need to Lead" by Dave Berke and discover why the best organizations don't just have good people they have good leaders who make people better. Your team is capable of more than you think. You just need to lead them differently.


Don't Miss Stories That Transform Perspectives

Subscribe to the Classic Pages newsletter for more book features that challenge conventions, spark conversations, and remind us that the best stories change not just how we read, but how we live.

Because some books entertain. The great ones? They awaken.

KS

Kamal Shukla

Founder & CEO, Classic Pages

Passionate about books and community, Kamal founded Classic Pages to create a vibrant space where readers connect, discover preloved treasures, and celebrate the magic of stories—one page, one heart, one bookshelf at a time.

Download Our Mobile App

Stay connected, get instant updates, and stay informed right from your phone.

Rent or Purchase Physical Book
Track Your Reading
Community for Book Lovers
Download from Playstore
Download from Appstore