The Love Story That’ll Break Your Heart in the Best Way

KS

Kamal Shukla

Founder & CEO

May 22, 2025
3 min read
The Love Story That’ll Break Your Heart in the Best Way

Have you ever met someone who changed the course of your entire life?

That’s exactly what happens when Lucy and Gabe meet on a September day in New York. One moment. One spark. And suddenly, everything begins to shift.

Story Overview

"The Light We Lost" tells the poignant story of Lucy and Gabe, two Columbia journalism students whose lives become intertwined on September 11, 2001. The novel follows their complex relationship over thirteen years, exploring how a single moment can change everything and how love persists even when life takes us in different directions.

The narrative examines the tension between following your heart and following your dreams, asking whether true love means being with someone or wanting what's best for them, even if that means letting them go.


Key Themes

Love and Sacrifice: The novel explores different forms of love and the sacrifices we make for those we care about.

Destiny vs. Choice: Questions whether our paths are predetermined or shaped by the decisions we make.

Timing: Examines how timing affects relationships and life's crucial moments.

Loss and Memory: Deals with how we process grief and keep memories alive.


What Readers Are Saying

This emotionally charged novel has resonated with readers who appreciate:

  • Complex, realistic characters
  • Beautifully crafted prose
  • Stories that explore moral ambiguity
  • Books that aren't afraid to tackle difficult emotions

Many readers praise Santopolo's ability to capture the intensity of first love and the pain of impossible choices.


Discussion Questions

  • How do you think the events of 9/11 shaped Lucy and Gabe's relationship?
  • What role does timing play in their story?
  • Do you believe Lucy made the right choices throughout the novel?
  • How does the author explore the idea that love sometimes means letting go?

About the Author

Jill Santopolo is an author and editor who has worked in children's publishing. "The Light We Lost" is her debut adult novel, though she has previously written several children's and young adult books. She currently lives in New York City.


Perfect For Readers Who Enjoyed

  • "Me Before You" by Jojo Moyes
  • "One Day" by David Nicholls
  • "The Time Traveler's Wife" by Audrey Niffenegger
  • "Eleanor Oliphant Is Completely Fine" by Gail Honeyman

"The Light We Lost" is a beautifully written exploration of love, loss, and the complexity of human relationships. While it may leave readers with mixed emotions, that's precisely the point—life rarely offers simple answers, and neither does this compelling novel.

Whether you're a fan of contemporary romance or literary fiction, this book offers a thoughtful examination of how our choices shape our lives and the people we love.


Discover the Joy of Reading with Classic Pages

Join a vibrant community where stories thrive, authors shine, and readers connect. Buy, rent, explore, and promote—all in one place.

📱 Now available on the App Store and Google Play. Download the Classic Pages app today and reshape the way you read.

Subscribe to continue reading

Get full access to this and all our newsletters by subscribing.

KS

Kamal Shukla

Founder & CEO, Classic Pages

Passionate about books and community, Kamal founded Classic Pages to create a vibrant space where readers connect, discover preloved treasures, and celebrate the magic of stories—one page, one heart, one bookshelf at a time.

Download Our Mobile App

Stay connected, get instant updates, and stay informed right from your phone.

Rent or Purchase Physical Book
Track Your Reading
Community for Book Lovers
Download from Playstore
Download from Appstore
The Love Story That’ll Break Your Heart in the Best Way